
Apple MacBook Pro 14" 2023 M3 8-Core 16GB 512GB SSD A2918 - Damaged Display
+$640 margin
$550Cracked screen
Tuscaloosa, AL
Short answer
Usually yes, when the seller names the fault. At today's median, a broken MacBook Pro costs $178 and a working one lists for $348, so 3 of the 8 common repairs leave real money after parts.
Live listings
22
Median as-is
$178
Median working
$348
Median spread
+$187
As-is prices are what sellers are asking for broken and for-parts units. Working value is the median price of active working-condition listings for the same model. Neither is a sold price, and the spread is not profit until you have paid for the part, the fees, and your time.
Parts cost for each common fault, and what the median spread leaves after it. "Worth it" means $100 or more left, or at least $40 that also pays back most of the buy-in. "Thin" is $30 or more. "Skip" is under $30.
| Fault | Parts | Left after fix | Call |
|---|---|---|---|
| Battery | $80 to $150 | +$72 | Thin |
| Screen / display | $120 to $300 | -$23 | Skip |
| Keyboard | $80 to $180 | +$57 | Thin |
| Trackpad | $40 to $90 | +$122 | Worth it |
| Charging port / charger | $30 to $90 | +$127 | Worth it |
| Won't boot / software (OS or storage) | $0 to $80 | +$147 | Worth it |
| Won't power on (battery / logic board) | $80 to $300 | -$3 | Skip |
| Liquid damage / logic board | $200 to $500 | -$163 | Skip |
Screens and batteries are documented swaps. No-power logic-board faults are the real risk; bid low when the seller is vague.
The stated fault on each live listing, grouped. "For parts only" means the seller named nothing, which is the listing to bid lowest on.
Cracked or damaged screen, a documented display-assembly swap.
Battery worn or swollen, a common, serviceable replacement.
No power or no boot, the logic-board risk, so bid low when the fault is vague.
Sold with no SSD or no OS, an easy, low-cost fix that scares off other buyers.

+$640 margin
$550Cracked screen
Tuscaloosa, AL

+$438 margin
$250Intermittent charging issue
Robbins, IL

+$500 margin
$460Damaged LCD
Naperville, IL

+$460 margin
$250Doesn't power on
Fort Worth, TX

+$475 margin
$380Damaged LCD
Saint Petersburg, FL

+$185 margin
$175Battery requires service
Houston, TX